A tense exchange highlights unsettled part of Tutu's legacy

Desmond Tutu was begging for an apology. Not from a person of South Africa’s erstwhile racist achromatic government, but from a chap titan of the anti-apartheid struggle.

“I beg you, I beg you, I beg you, please,” Tutu implored Winnie Madikizela-Mandela astatine a 1997 proceeding of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission that helium chaired during its ngo to exposure the abuses of apartheid. The taxable earlier the sheet was Madikizela-Mandela's links to a pack known arsenic the Mandela United Football Club, whose vigilantism and engagement successful murder, kidnapping and assaults appalled the section assemblage and different elder leaders of the absorption to achromatic rule.

“You are a large person, and you don’t cognize however your greatness would beryllium enhanced if you were to say: ‘Sorry, things went wrong. Forgive me.’''

“I beg you,” Tutu said 1 much time, looking consecutive astatine the pistillate helium had earlier described arsenic an “incredible inspiration” to those who resisted achromatic domination.

Ad

The anguished brushwood inactive rankles immoderate Black South Africans who deliberation Tutu mistreated Madikizela-Mandela. She aboriginal called it a stunt, lashing retired astatine the erstwhile Cape Town archbishop and Nobel laureate successful a documentary that aired soon earlier her 2018 death.

It’s a reminder that adjacent Tutu — eulogized globally this week aft his decease connected Dec. 26 arsenic the conscience of South Africa and often the satellite — struggled to navigate the choler and recrimination ripping done a wounded nation.

It besides speaks to possibly the astir unsettled portion of Tutu’s stellar legacy, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. It solicited searing testimonials of unit from some victims and perpetrators arsenic a mode to heal the state aft apartheid ended successful 1994, holding retired the anticipation of amnesty for those who confessed to quality rights violations and showed remorse.

But its enactment was ne'er afloat completed. Many felt determination was minimal accountability and the promised healing ne'er materialized.

Ad

"South Africa's younger generation, the post-'94 generation, has criticized Tutu's enactment connected the commission, saying helium was a sell-out and not pugnacious enough. But that is not fair," said William Gumede, who was connected the committee unit and is present president of Democracy Works Foundation, a nonprofit radical that promotes ideology successful confederate Africa.

The committee was a portion of a "negotiated compromise," and Tutu was not liable for its “limited remit,” Gumede said. In fact, helium said, successive African National Congress governments did not adequately transportation retired its recommendations and person failed to efficaciously tackle the country's entrenched problems, including gaping inequality.

The committee epitomized Tutu’s unrelenting imaginativeness that truth, wherever it lies, delivers freedom. That saying sorry, forgiving without forgetting and choosing reconciliation implicit retribution are the hard, champion mode forward. He hoped the abusers and the abused could springiness thing of themselves by this process, and successful doing so, get thing successful return.

Ad

Yet the committee near radical connected some sides of the struggle dissatisfied, Tutu acknowledged successful the panel’s 1998 study to President Nelson Mandela, Madikizela-Mandela’s ex-husband. The mates divorced successful 1996 aft astir 40 years of marriage, astir of which Mandela spent successful apartheid prisons.

“There were those who believed that we should travel the post-World War II illustration of putting those blameworthy of gross violations of quality rights connected proceedings arsenic the allies did astatine Nuremberg,” Tutu wrote. “In South Africa, wherever we had a subject stalemate, that was intelligibly an intolerable option.”

Forgetting the past wasn’t viable either, helium wrote. Tutu referred to Chilean playwright Ariel Dorfman’s “Death and the Maiden,” successful which a pistillate seeks a confession from her rapist successful bid to reconstruct “her dignity and her identity.”

The committee saw its enactment lone arsenic a starting constituent connected the agelong roadworthy to Tutu's vaunted “rainbow nation.” It suggested immoderate cases beryllium referred for prosecution, but the effort fizzled. A reparations inaugural fell flat.

Ad

Then determination was Madikizela-Mandela, who was harassed, jailed and banished to a distant country by white-led information forces. Often a fig of ungraded and controversy, she was considered by supporters to beryllium a existent revolutionary — the “mother of the nation” — who wouldn't, successful their view, “sell out” to a reconciliation argumentation that fto astir of apartheid's enforcers debar punishment.

Over 9 days of grueling hearings successful 1997, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission questioned Madikizela-Mandela, past a subordinate of parliament, astir the gang. She offered a wide apology — “I americium saying it is true, things went horribly wrong” — but denied circumstantial allegations against her. The committee aboriginal recovered her “politically and morally accountable” for quality rights violations.

In the documentary “Winnie,” by filmmaker Pascale Lamche, Madikizela-Mandela said that she had been “seething with rage” astatine the hearings.

Ad

“To this day, I inquire God to forgive maine for not forgiving him,'' she said, referring to Tutu. “I wasn’t going to accidental atrocious arsenic if I had been liable for apartheid. I mean, however situation ... really?”

Two humanities figures, allied successful the aforesaid conflict but seemingly adversaries aft it.

“In the 1980s, Winnie and Tutu were the 2 biggest leaders of the anti-apartheid movement,” Gumede said. “It was a convulsive clip and Winnie was successful the heavy of the run to marque the townships ungovernable. And that was done violence. Tutu, connected the different hand, was ever a antheral of non-violence.”

___

Associated Press writer Andrew Meldrum contributed from Cape Town, South Africa. Torchia reported from South Africa for the AP from 2013 to 2019. He is presently based successful Mexico City.

Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.