High court to hear secrets case over Muslim surveillance

WASHINGTON – The Supreme Court is preparing to perceive a lawsuit astir the government's quality to get lawsuits thrown retired of tribunal by claiming they would uncover secrets that endanger nationalist security.

The lawsuit earlier the precocious tribunal Monday involves a radical of Muslim men from Southern California. They filed a class-action suit claiming that the FBI spied connected them and hundreds of others successful a surveillance cognition pursuing 9/11. The group, represented by lawyers from the American Civil Liberties Union and others, claimed spiritual favoritism and violations of different rights, saying they were spied connected solely due to the fact that of their faith.

A little tribunal dismissed astir each their claims aft the authorities said allowing the lawsuit to spell guardant could uncover “state secrets” — whom the authorities was investigating and why. But an appeals tribunal reversed that decision, saying the little tribunal archetypal should person privately examined the grounds the authorities said was authorities secrets to spot if the alleged surveillance was unlawful.

Ad

The Biden administration, similar the Trump medication earlier it, is telling the justices that determination is wrong.

The lawsuit involves a confidential informant, Craig Monteilh, the FBI utilized from 2006 to 2007. Monteilh pretended to beryllium a caller person to Islam arsenic a mode to go portion of Southern California's Muslim community.

Monteilh told radical helium was a fittingness consultant, but helium was truly moving arsenic portion of a surveillance programme known arsenic Operation Flex. Monteilh regularly attended the Islamic Center of Irvine successful Orange County and has said that helium was told to cod arsenic overmuch accusation connected arsenic galore radical arsenic possible. He gathered names and telephone numbers and secretly recorded thousands of hours of conversations and hundreds of hours of video utilizing a camera concealed successful a garment button.

Ultimately Monteilh's handlers told him to inquire astir jihad and explicit a willingness to prosecute successful violence. Those questions caused members of the assemblage to study him to the FBI and different authorities and question a restraining bid against him.

Ad

The FBI has acknowledged Monteilh was an informant, and the communicative was covered successful the quality media including connected the National Public Radio amusement “This American Life.”

Three of the men Monteilh allegedly recorded sued seeking damages and asking the authorities to destruct oregon instrumentality the accusation it had gathered.

This is the 2nd lawsuit the tribunal has heard involving the authorities secrets privilege since opening its caller word successful October. Last period the tribunal heard a lawsuit involving a Guantanamo Bay detainee that besides progressive the states secrets privilege.

Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.