Mystery lingers around cause of California oil pipeline leak

3 years ago 223

HUNTINGTON BEACH, Calif. – Investigators searching for the origin of an lipid pipeline interruption disconnected the Southern California seashore person pointed to the anticipation that a vessel anchor dragged the enactment crossed the seabed and cracked it, but 2 videos released truthful acold supply lone tantalizing clues astir what mightiness person happened 100 feet (30 meters) beneath the water surface.

A Coast Guard video released Thursday appears to amusement a trench successful the seafloor starring to a crook successful the submerged line, but experts offered varied opinions of the value of the brief, grainy shots. An earlier video revealed a 13-inch (33-centimeter) rupture successful the line, but the tube showed nary grounds of harm that they said would beryllium expected from a collision with a multi-ton anchor from cargo ships that routinely determination done the country disconnected the ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach.

The flimsy bow successful the enactment displayed successful 1 video “doesn’t needfully look similar anchor damage,” Frank G. Adams, president of Houston-based Interface Consulting International, said successful an email. When a pipeline is deed by an anchor oregon different dense entity “that typically results successful carnal harm that whitethorn pb to a fracture.”

Ramanan Krishnamoorti, a petroleum engineering prof astatine the University of Houston, said helium considered the video that runs on a crook successful the enactment “revealing.”

“It seems to maine you’ve got thing that was dragged successful the soil that mightiness person impacted the pipeline,” helium said. However, helium remained puzzled that the leak came from a ace and not a larger gash, assuming it was deed by an anchor oregon immoderate different object.

Key questions remain: Could the enactment person been deed days earlier the leak started? What vessel is responsible? And if a vessel anchor is not the culprit, what other could it be?

Investigators, meanwhile, continued to hunt for the origin of the interruption that spilled tens of thousands of gallons of crude lipid disconnected the famed surf breaks of Huntington Beach, arsenic good arsenic find what happened successful the important aboriginal hours aft reports of a imaginable lipid spill archetypal came in.

The 13-inch-long (33-centimeter), constrictive gash seen successful 1 video could explicate wherefore signs of an lipid slick were seen Friday night, but the spill eluded detection by the pipeline relation until Saturday morning, experts said.

“My acquisition suggests this would beryllium a darned hard leak to remotely find quickly,” said Richard Kuprewicz, a backstage pipeline mishap researcher and consultant. “An opening of this type, connected a 17-mile-long (27-kilometer) underwater tube is precise hard to spot by distant indications. These crack-type releases are little complaint and tin spell for rather a while.”

When pipes acquisition a catastrophic failure, the breach typically is overmuch bigger, what’s referred to successful the manufacture arsenic a “fish mouth” rupture due to the fact that it gapes wide similar the rima of a fish, helium said.

Amplify Energy, a Houston-based institution that owns and operates 3 offshore lipid platforms and the pipeline southbound of Los Angeles, said it didn’t cognize determination had been a spill until its workers detected an lipid sheen connected the h2o Saturday astatine 8:09 a.m.

The origin of the spill is nether probe by galore agencies arsenic the cleanup continues on miles of shoreline connected the Orange County seashore southbound of the sister ports.

The Coast Guard connected Thursday somewhat revised spill estimates to astatine slightest astir 25,000 gallons (95,000 liters) and nary much than 132,000 gallons (500,000 liters).

The Coast Guard connected Thursday said it is investigating the incidental with different agencies arsenic a “major marine casualty” owed to the imaginable engagement of a vas and damages exceeding $500,000. It said they volition find if transgression charges, civilian penalties oregon caller laws oregon regulations are needed.

The leak occurred astir 5 miles (8 kilometers) offshore astatine a extent of astir 98 feet (30 meters), investigators said. A 4,000-foot (1,219-meter) conception of the pipeline was dislodged 105 feet (32 meters), bent backmost similar the drawstring connected a bow, Amplify’s CEO Martyn Willsher has said.

Jonathan Stewart, a prof of civilian and biology engineering astatine the University of California, Los Angeles, said helium was amazed the harm wasn’t much terrible fixed however acold the tube was moved.

“My archetypal absorption erstwhile I heard that it is displaced truthful acold was that it’s singular that it’s adjacent intact astatine all,” Stewart said.

Moving a ample conception of tube up to 105 feet (32 meters) would person caused “bending deformations” – hostility connected the broadside that was stretched into a semicircle, with compression connected the other, arsenic it was bent inward, Stewart said.

It’s imaginable specified unit unsocial could effect successful a break, though Stewart said determination is excessively small accusation to marque a decision astir the cause. It's imaginable a crisp conception of anchor could pierce the pipeline but “you could inactive person harm conscionable from the bending.”

“Because it’s pulling connected the pipe, you make these bending stresses successful the pipe, which could yet go ample capable that they rupture it,” helium said.

Questions stay astir erstwhile the lipid institution knew it had a occupation and delays successful reporting the spill.

A overseas vessel anchored successful the waters disconnected Huntington Beach reported to the Coast Guard that it saw a sheen longer than 2 miles (3 kilometers) conscionable aft 6 p.m. A outer representation changeable by the European Space Agency indicated a apt lipid slick successful the country astir 7 p.m., which was reported to the Coast Guard astatine 2:06 a.m. Saturday aft being reviewed by a National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration analyst.

Federal pipeline information regulators person enactment the clip of the incidental astatine 2:30 a.m. Saturday but accidental the institution didn't unopen down the pipeline until 6:01 a.m. and didn't study the leak to the Coast Guard until 9:07 a.m. Federal and authorities rules necessitate contiguous notification of spills.

Willsher, who took questions alongside Coast Guard and different officials implicit 4 days, did not amusement up astatine Thursday's quality conference. Other officials declined to explicate his absence.

The benignant of ace seen successful the Coast Guard video is large capable to let immoderate lipid to flight to perchance trigger the debased unit alarm, Kuprewicz said. But due to the fact that the pipeline was operating nether comparatively debased pressure, the power country relation whitethorn person simply dismissed the alarm due to the fact that the unit was not precise precocious to begin, helium said.

Because the enactment is encased successful factual — a means of keeping it weighted down connected the oversea level — the Coast Guard videos don’t uncover the information of the half-inch-thick alloy tube underneath.

Once national information investigators chopped retired the damaged conception of tube and region it, they volition beryllium capable to behaviour a person examination, looking for signs of corrosion, metallic fatigue oregon different anomalies that would person made it much susceptible to failure. That introspection should besides uncover if the ace grew larger implicit time, Kuprewicz said.

___

Michael R. Blood contributed from Los Angeles.

Read Entire Article