Tennessee judge vacates 2 death sentences for inmate

MEMPHIS, Tenn. – Moments earlier a Tennessee justice freed him from decease row, Pervis Payne walked into a courtroom, hugged his lawyer and wept.

Payne, who was sentenced to decease successful the 1987 killings of a parent and daughter, held lawyer Kelley Henry tightly and thanked her for arguing that helium is intellectually disabled and cannot beryllium executed nether a comparatively caller Tennessee law.

“He conscionable hugged maine and conscionable said ‘thank you,’ implicit and implicit and implicit again,” Henry told reporters aft a proceeding Tuesday successful a Memphis courtroom. “I told him it was alright, 'I got you.’”

Shelby County Criminal Court Judge Paula Skahan signed an bid vacating Payne's 2 decease sentences handed down much than 30 years ago. Payne was convicted connected execution charges successful the stabbing deaths of Charisse Christopher and her 2-year-old daughter, Lacie Jo, successful the Memphis suburb of Millington. Christopher’s son, Nicholas, who was 3 astatine the time, besides was stabbed but survived.

Ad

The justice took enactment aft Shelby County territory lawyer Amy Weirich announced Friday that the authorities volition nary longer prosecute its execution plans aft an adept hired by prosecutors “could not accidental that Payne’s intelligence functioning is extracurricular the scope for intelligence disability."

Payne's lawyers had filed a petition claiming Payne is intellectually disabled and brought successful their ain adept to analyse him.

“The Petition is supported by 2 adept opinions concluding that Petitioner is intellectually disabled pursuant to Tennessee law,” the justice wrote successful her order.

Payne present faces 2 beingness sentences. Prosecutors are pushing for consecutive beingness sentences, which would mean Payne would not beryllium eligible for parole until helium is 85, his lawyer said. Henry is arguing for the beingness sentences to tally astatine the aforesaid time, meaning Payne could go eligible for parole overmuch sooner.

Payne, who is Black, has ever maintained his innocence. He told constabulary helium was astatine Christopher’s flat gathering to conscionable his woman erstwhile helium heard the victims, who were white, and tried to assistance them. He said helium panicked erstwhile helium saw a achromatic policeman and ran away.

Ad

The lawsuit has drawn nationalist attraction from anti-death-penalty activists and includes the engagement of the Innocence Project, which argues for the usage of DNA investigating successful cases claiming wrongful conviction. DNA tests failed to exonerate Payne.

Weirich, the territory attorney, has said the grounds overwhelmingly points to Payne arsenic the slayer and her bureau initially contested the intelligence disablement claims. A weapon that was utilized arsenic the execution weapon, a washcloth and different bloody items were recovered astatine the scene.

“While the grounds of Payne’s guilt has ne'er alteration oregon weakened, the laws regarding alleged intelligence disablement arsenic it related to the decease punishment person changed,” Weirich told reporters Friday.

Executions of the mentally disabled were ruled unconstitutional successful 2002, erstwhile the U.S. Supreme Court recovered they interruption the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition connected cruel and antithetic punishment.

But until Republican Gov. Bill Lee signed a measure this summertime making Tennessee’s instrumentality retroactive successful prohibiting the execution of the intellectually disabled, Tennessee had nary mechanics for an inmate to reopen a lawsuit to property an intelligence disablement claim.

Ad

“The instrumentality was critical, because, for astir a decade, the authorities has hid down procedural obstacles, and the Legislature wiped those obstacles away,” Henry said.

Payne had been scheduled to beryllium enactment to decease past December, but the execution was delayed aft the politician granted him a rare, impermanent reprieve due to the fact that of the COVID-19 pandemic. The reprieve expired successful April, but the authorities Supreme Court had not acceptable a caller execution day yet.

Henry and authoritative Steve Jones are expected to contiguous arguments successful tribunal Dec. 13 concerning the contented of consecutive versus concurrent sentences. Henry said she continues to look for grounds that could exonerate Payne.

Payne besides has received the enactment of clergy from the Church of God successful Christ, and his family, including his aged begetter Carl Payne and his sister, Rolanda Holman.

Holman said she remembers a justice sentencing her member to decease by electrocution much than 3 decades ago, and the justice telling Pervis Payne “may God person mercy connected his soul.”

Ad

“Thirty-four years later, God did person mercy connected his soul,” Holman said.

Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.